
By Dave Hunter
Fun and accessible drinks backed by top quality service is the proposition at one of Edinburgh’s newest cocktail bars.
Understory opened its doors beneath The Rutland hotel in September, in the space that was previously the gin-themed Heads & Tales.
The Rutland is owned by Signature Pubs and the creation of the new bar began with a conversation between Rutland director Mike Lewis and the hotel’s head of bars, James Grant, about making some changes to the space.

“At the start of the year discussions started with Mike about making some changes and reinvigorating the space,” James told SLTN last month.
“The space hadn’t been changed since 2014.
“The gin thing has kind of run its course, and we’re also in a unique position where we have a lot of good people that work in this building and so let’s really show what we can do if we put our minds to it.

“The discussion started with a light bulb – which is kind of a joke now. Mike had brought it up with (Signature owner Nic Wood) and he said ‘what would happen if I gave you and James a bit more money? What would you do with it, what would that look like?’
“It was very exciting to be involved in every step of that, and I appreciate Mike giving me the opportunity to get so in-depth.
“It started as a lightbulb and turned into an entire venue.”
Plans were drawn up for the new ‘five star dive bar’ and a new general manager recruited in the form of veteran bartender Sam Baxendale.

Formerly GM of Edinburgh institution Bramble, Sam has been behind the stick in Edinburgh for more than 20 years.
“Mike Lewis had been passed my name by a mutual friend, and he said they were starting a new project and was it something I might be interested in,” Sam told SLTN.
“I’m always up for a conversation. I’ve been doing this for a long time, I’m not getting any younger, and it was that thing of new challenges, new structure.

“I came and met James and the team and the attitude and the drive for what we want to do aligned.
“I love the team I was with, but this was too good to pass up.”
Meanwhile, the former Heads & Tales was being extensively refurbished to create Understory, which included fresh lighting, paint and wallpaper as well as new furniture.
The bar has a capacity of 90 people, and on busier nights the team can find themselves serving 350 covers.
The drinks offer at the bar revolves around nostalgia.
The first iteration, created by James and described by Sam as ‘ridiculous in the best way’, includes the Parkside Bucky (which combines Vivir tequila with Four Pillars Bloody Shiraz gin, spiced Buckfast amaro and lemon); the Sgroppino (dessert wine, verjus, peach aperitif, IRN-BRU and tonka bean sorbet); and the Trip to the Pub (Angostura 1919, Smith & Cross, banana, chocolate and Oolong Tea).
“The approachability of the menu makes it so fun to serve,” said Sam.
“Every menu will be based around some point of nostalgia. The first one is Halcyon Days based around British nostalgic flavours. Even if you’re not from the UK there’s something relatable in there.
“When you serve the drinks to the guests there are these tongue in cheek or whimsical parts and you see people’s faces light up.

“Fun, sweet shop menus are not necessarily anything new, but I think the way James has put these together and created the drinks, they are a little bit more sophisticated.
“So if the customer is interested in cocktail culture you can go into all of that. But you can also just smash the drinks.”
James said that fun was the main aim of the drinks list when he was developing it.
“You don’t need to care about it to enjoy it,” he said.
“I think sometimes in the bar industry we can get a little bit too carried away, and it starts to become not really about the guests and the enjoyment. And we’ve tried to make sure that is still front and centre. If you want to engage with us about it we will nerd out with you. You can come into our lab and we’ll show you everything. If you just want to sit there and crush drinks then we’re so game for that as well.”
Service is another cornerstone of the bar, and extensive prep is done ahead of opening to ensure more time can be spent on customer interaction.
In addition to the drinks list, the bar also serves a selection of snacks and small plates that have been proving popular with the venue’s customer base of locals and tourists.
Sam said: “The product we are passionate about is mixed drinks and cocktails, but one of the things when James and I started talking was this idea that if you’re coming in for a beer or a glass of wine, whatever it is, you’re just as welcome. It’s not ‘oh, you’re just having a pint?’ We want you to come in and enjoy the space. And I think that does bring a huge variety of people in.”























