- Advertisement -
front cover of SLTN magazine
front cover of SLTN magazine

Insolvency does not need to be the end of a hospitality business

Insolvency
You could end up with some light at the end of a dark tunnel and trade on, but you have to do it properly.

With the right advice, businesses can restructure and retain their customers

by Alan McKee of MCM Solicitors

What’s in a name?

As much as I am sure he enjoyed some fine dining and convivial company of an evening, William Shakespeare did not have the importance and value associated with the name of a licensed premises in mind when he asked that question, but the concept of the importance of a name was evident, even in the 1600s.

Everyone has their favourite TV bar, be it Cheers or one of the Queen Vic or Rovers Return.  

In many TV shows, a bar or restaurant is a staple setting for many a memorable scene.

What is different in TV world is that none of our favourite hospitality outlets have endured the difficulties facing the industry in recent years. 

Industry Challenges 

While cultural and generational changes were becoming apparent before the Covid 19 Pandemic, the restrictions enforced on the hospitality industry were seismic.  They required to close. Immediately and for an indefinite period. Financial support was minimal and uncertainty was rampant.  

Enter the Bounce Back Loan or BBL. While more than a little helpful at the time, this has been a cause of great difficulty down the line – more on this later.

After a period of stop/start openings as we navigated the restrictions and new waves of infection, when fully lifted, trade never quite felt the same. 

People had less money to spend and had become accustomed to dining and drinking at home.  

While it happened pre-pandemic, Covid 19 masked the true impact of Brexit, but the chickens eventually came home to roost. Staff became harder to source from abroad, particularly skilled kitchen staff, and produce became more expensive.

Transport in and out of major towns  and cities was impacted by strike action and many in the taxi industry pivoted to courier and food delivery services and didn’t come back. So, for those who did decide to have an evening out, they had difficulty getting home. After a few instances of frustration, the custom tailed off.

Then came the energy crisis. 

It is open to interpretation whether you consider it a crisis or a scandal but the facts are simple, the cost of heating and lighting a premises increased significantly.

Reeling from all of this, with a flick of the legislative pen, employers’ contributions to National Insurance Contributions for staff were increased. 

If they managed to survive all of this, then came the Business Rates…

There is a limit to how much you can charge for a pint of Guinness or a bowl of pasta at the end of the day.

Survival 

While there are some who have and continue to manage the seemingly never-ending storm of rising costs and reduced trade – and genuinely hats off to them – there are many who simply found themselves unable to meet the demands.  

The increased costs of doing business was enough to cause sleepless nights without having any, previously manageable, legacy debt to service; but many did have.

I say manageable on the basis that the income and cost ratio can carry debt servicing in the ordinary course, but added to that the Bounce Back Loans repayments were now due. 

For many licensed trade operators it was too much and the constant payment demands begun to overtake what was otherwise a successful business.

Insolvency is a word that people associate with recklessness or failure. That is not always the case and in many insolvency scenarios, it can occur through no fault of the owner and all that could have been done had been done, but it wasn’t enough.

Insolvency

Restructure and keeping the name

While the option is always there to simply close the doors and go and do something else and indeed many did, there is another option which is to restructure and save the business, if not the limited company entity.

For many it was the legacy debt, BBL loans and debts accrued throughout the periods of uncertainty which, coupled with the rising costs noted above, was crushing what was otherwise a sustainable business.  

Working with the relevant professionals and within the parameters of the relevant law allowed many to restructure the business to allow a streamlined business plan to be implemented in line with the current costs base in a new company and the legacy debt remaining within the old company.

The law does not simply permit parties to ‘flip’ the business and the new company will have to have the assets valued and make payment to the old company if they wish to use them.  

Another consequence is in the restrictions in reuse of the company or trading name for a period of five years after the old company enters liquidation. 

While you cannot have a bar or restaurant without tables, chairs or stock to turn into tasty food, equally important to success of the new business is the ability to continue to use the name that everyone knows. 

Thanks to a legal process regulated by the Insolvency Act 1986, the name can often be retained. 

After all, many people only know the name of the premises and not the company, the owner or even the chef. 

Final Thought

I know my local publicans, Stevie and Dot. I know my local restauranteur, Pino.  They and many others have come through an extremely challenging period and the challenges keep coming.

If you have encountered the difficulties noted in this article, speak to a professional who can guide you through your options.

You could end up with some light at the end of a dark tunnel and trade on, but you have to do it properly.

The place “where everyone knows your name” can survive and after a period of gloom the Rovers really can, Return. 

Alan McKee of MCM Solictors

Alan@mcmsolicitors

0141 488 3680

mcmsolicitors.co.uk